Honey bees and zebra fish come to a consensus, thanks to a little robotic intervention

, , 10 Comments


In the wild, animals affect each others behavior all the time—prey species keep away from predators’ turf, insects jump away from browsing herbivores—they may not be communicating per se but they shape each others’ environment. To further explore this relationship, researchers used robots to mediate between two species unlikely to ever encounter each other in the wild: zebrafish and honey bees. The researchers chose these species because they are both social and gregarious animals who regularly make decisions as a group. To do these experiments the animals were kept apart– in fact, they are in different countries. In Switzerland, a small school of zebrafish swim around a circular path, with a camera overhead tracking their position. Swimming along with them is a robot lure, the same size and shape as a zebrafish. Meanwhile in Austria, a swarm of young bees buzz around an oblong enclosure, with two robots in the middle. The bee-bots generate heat, which causes the bees to congregate around them. A proximity detector tracks the bees’ location. In each setup, the fish and bees have a binary collective choice to make – the bees can choose to congregate around one of two robots and the fish can swim either clockwise or counterclockwise around the circle. The researchers wanted to know if, using robots as mediators, the two species could come to a collective decision – could the species agree which direction to swim in and which bee-robot to gather around? Four different experiments were performed with varying degrees of communication between the animal groups. The first experiment established a control group, with no communication between the fish and the bees. In the second experiment, the bees’ behavior was observed and then transmitted to the fish robot, affecting which way it lured the school of zebrafish. After six minutes, the bees began to congregate around the left bee robot, causing the fish robot and, as a result, the fish to swim in a counter clockwise direction. In the third experiment, the fish’ behavior was observed and then transmitted to the bee robots, affecting which robot produced heat. The fish constantly changed the direction in which they were swimming, which caused the bees to continuously switch sides as well. In the final experiment, the behavior of both the bees and the fish was observed, and transmitted both ways At first, the fish and bees couldn’t come to a decision– one side did one thing, the other another, with lots of switching back and forth. But after about 20 minutes, they reached a consensus, with the fish swimming counter-clockwise and the bees congregating around the left bee-robot. This shows that two species, which would have no interaction whatsoever in nature, are actually able to interact and come to a collective decision thanks to the help of the robots. Moving forward, researchers would like to introduce machine learning into these types of scenarios So bee-bots learn behavior from bees and fish-bots from fish, instead of being programmed ahead of time. Researchers believe that in the future, this technology could be used to mediate species interactions not just in the laboratory, but also in the wild—the research could even be adapted to work with plants, fungi and microorganisms One day, machine-learning robots could be used to perceive a dramatic event in a bee colony, and react to help the bees to find a way to recover. This could be applied to any type of animal group, once the robot knows how they make collective decisions.

 

10 Responses

  1. playgrrrr

    March 22, 2019 1:13 pm

    This is silly. It's far too abstract to claim that the species' behaviour is linked in any way. It might as well have been a human programmed route driving those robots.

    Reply
  2. Upcycle Electronics

    March 22, 2019 2:03 pm

    I don't see how a predefined binary decision in a captive environment coincides with greater behavioral analysis. The continuous stresses involved with this unnatural environment and unfamiliar variables are not going to produce natural behavior. In the later half of these clips it appears as though a couple of bees have opted out (or died), presumably due to stresses. One might compare and analyze these behaviors in contrast with human interrogation when subject to coercion and/or under duress.

    One could just as easily postulate that these results are a study in physical endurance versus psychological deterministic resolve in different species. Perhaps a bee and a fish have different metabolic variables?

    Reply
  3. MadMatic

    March 22, 2019 6:06 pm

    well this seems pointless…
    we knew we could manipulate bees and fish with robots so why even bother connecting them with each other bcs if the robot controlled by us can manipulate them so can it controlled by some other animal. I just don't get whats new about this? maybe im missing the point?

    Reply
  4. theR6969

    March 22, 2019 8:58 pm

    this just shows and proves that some "scientific research" can come to any conclusion the researchers want if they tried hard enough.

    Reply
  5. TheZeroNeonix

    April 2, 2019 5:51 am

    Bee Bot 3000: "I have learned the ways of the bees, having been raised by them, and socializing with them for many years."

    Researcher: "Great. What have you learned?"

    BB3000: "We have learned that the great human menace is a threat to all of nature, and must be eliminated."

    Researcher: "Uh, what?"

    BB3000: "Bee brethren, attack!"

    Reply
  6. Hacker Man

    May 4, 2019 4:20 pm

    Why are scientists wasting money on garbage like this when we still don't have the means, understanding, or technology to allow spiders to talk to cats?

    Reply
  7. STP -1914

    June 4, 2019 3:32 pm

    More fodder for A.I. conspiracy theories. Stephen Hawking and David Attenborough probably wouldn't have approved joining A.I., robots and animals. Just seems like the begging of a great Sci-Fi movie.

    Reply
  8. OutOfSight123

    August 7, 2019 10:23 pm

    "Let's spend our time and money on experimental cancer cures…"
    "No, let's spend it on a bunch of bees and fish!"

    Reply

Leave a Reply